Game reviews / Madden NFL 24
Madden NFL 24
2023 · PC · PlayStation 4 · PlayStation 5 · Xbox One · Xbox Series X|S · Sports · Simulation · American football · Team-based
4 scored sources · 2 countries contributing scores
Review consensus
Madden NFL 24 makes meaningful progress on the field, with improved blocking, more natural player movement, expanded tackle and catch animations, better defensive behavior, and a convincing visual upgrade through the SAPIEN character system. Cross-play is also a welcome addition, while Franchise receives useful roster-management tools and returning training minigames. However, the broader package remains frustratingly conservative. Slow menus, bugs, crashes, repetitive minigames, generic Superstar storytelling, persistent Franchise issues, and heavy Ultimate Team emphasis undermine the improvements. Critics generally found it to be a solid and authentic football simulation, but one held back by an annual-release structure that limits meaningful innovation.
Limited geographic coverage. Treat this score as an early indication.
Last researched: 2026-09-23
Pros
- More authentic on-field gameplay and improved blocking
- Large variety of tackles, catches, and player animations
- SAPIEN character models improve realism and presentation
- Cross-play and Franchise management additions are useful
Cons
- Sluggish menus, bugs, and occasional crashes
- Training minigames become repetitive and can feel mandatory
- Superstar mode has generic storytelling and limited customization
- Overall design feels too iterative, with continued Ultimate Team emphasis
Review sources
4 sources found across 2 countries. This is not exhaustive worldwide coverage.
- Push Square · United Kingdom · 70/100
- TheSixthAxis · United Kingdom · 60/100
- Game Informer · United States · 67.5/100
- GameSpot · United States · 50/100